Test report DSG-5742 · Rev E · tested November 16, 2026

Supply Chain & PolicyDevice under test

Samsung, SK hynix and Micron Must Face DRAM Price-Fixing Suit

U.S. Judge Noel Wise denied Samsung, SK hynix and Micron's bid to stall a DRAM price-fixing class action filed by 14 consumers and three PC firms, sending supply-cut claims to the merits.

Read
3 min
Words
549
Node
3nm
Operator
Amara Osei

Spec summary

  1. Judge Noel Wise denied the stay motions on the 14th; the ruling was reviewed on the 16th.
  2. 14 U.S. consumers and three small PC assemblers and distributors filed the class action in June.
  3. Plaintiffs put the three defendants' combined market share at about 90%.
  4. DDR4 output reductions were announced between April and June last year, and similar review procedures were adopted in January.
  5. Companies must file answers by Dec. 7; the first case management conference is set for Jan. 12.
U.S. Court Denies Samsung, SK hynix Bid to Halt DRAM Price-Fixing Suit
Fig. AU.S. Court Denies Samsung, SK hynix Bid to Halt DRAM Price-Fixing Suit — 2427999 / pixabay

By Amara Osei

On the 14th, Judge Noel Wise denied Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron’s request to halt a class action alleging DRAM price fixing. The order, posted on CourtListener, a nonprofit U.S. court-records database, was reviewed on the 16th.

It advances a June filing by 14 U.S. consumers and three small PC assemblers and distributors. The plaintiffs allege that the three suppliers exploited an oligopoly position with about 90% combined market share to curb DRAM supply and raise prices.

What did the court decide?

The ruling lets the case naming Samsung Electronics (005930.KS), SK hynix (000660.KS) and Micron continue. The plaintiffs say the three companies exploited an oligopoly position to engineer artificial supply shortages and reap improper gains. They characterize the conduct as price fixing and put the defendants’ combined market share at about 90%.

The judge set a limited procedural boundary. He said the alleged facts were plausible enough for the case to move forward, but had not reached a full determination that collusion occurred.

Takeaway: The court found the alleged collusion plausible enough to continue, not proven.

Why did the supply-restriction claims survive the stay request?

Wise focused on the timing of the companies’ production and review decisions.

  • Memory output cuts, shifts toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM) production and halts to DDR4, a commodity DRAM product, occurred at similar times.
  • Samsung, SK hynix and Micron successively announced DDR4 output reductions between April and June last year.
  • In January, the companies adopted similar review procedures to verify customers’ end demand and order volumes.

Wise said the production decisions and review procedures may be difficult to view as independent actions by individual firms. He treated the timing as support for the plaintiffs’ plausibility argument, not as a final finding that the companies coordinated.

The defendants rejected the possibility of collusion. Samsung, SK hynix and Micron said they were “watching each other like hawks” and argued that this explained the apparent similarity in their conduct.

Wise countered: “plaintiffs’ allegations go beyond watching one another and are closer to hawks flying in formation, which hawks do not ordinarily do.” The comparison described the plausibility of the plaintiffs’ coordinated-conduct theory; it did not establish liability.

Takeaway: Synchronized output decisions and review practices supplied a plausible coordination theory for the case to test.

What changes for DRAM buyers and the case timetable?

The companies now proceed to the merits phase in the U.S. court. They must file answers by Dec. 7, and the court scheduled the first case management conference for Jan. 12.

The immediate market effect is limited to litigation risk: three suppliers with roughly 90% combined market share remain subject to U.S. claims over supply restraint. The order does not change DRAM output, prices or customer contracts.

Wise did not resolve whether the parallel conduct was independent or coordinated. He has only concluded that the plaintiffs’ account is plausible enough to proceed, leaving the companies to answer the allegations and the court to manage the dispute.

Any final conclusion on collusion awaits the merits phase. The Dec. 7 answers will put the companies’ formal positions on record before the court.

Takeaway: The next fixed dates are Dec. 7 for answers and Jan. 12 for the first case management conference.

via en.sedaily.com (Source)

Filed under

  • dram
  • samsung-electronics
  • sk-hynix
  • micron
  • price-fixing
Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Staff writer covering money, funding and market shifts around hardware layer of artificial intelligence at Die Signal.

698 articles

Same lot · LOT-362C

« Previous articleNext article »